It will definitely be interesting to see how the magazines handle these cars. I was stunned and shocked that Road & Track, Car & Driver, and Motor Trend have all just published comparison testing between the 2005 Pontiac GTO and the 2005 Mustang GT and all three showed strong "numerical" advantage hands down in favor of the GTO. But when it came to adding the final two scores of esthectics and price, all three swung the numbers to allow the Mustang to beat the GTO as the overall winner.
Now if we can extrapolate that thinking INTO the future and see the E55 AMG Wagon and/or Audi RS Avant against the Dodge Magnum SRT-8, then it would seem to follow that regardless of the actual numbers, the SRT-8 Magnum will be the hands down overall winner. I have seen the RS Avant and the E55 AMG Wagon, and they are Euro stylish which means boring. The Magnum has splash, pizzazz, and spirit to go with all that Horsepower. It also has cubic inches and no superchargers or turbochargers to create that horsepower.
Okay, it's a Dodge, and that may not conjur up visions of Quality Control. But I'd rather pay for something out of warranty out-of-pocket on a Dodge, than at the other two dealerships. I deal with the Porsche and Mercedes dealerships (Brumos) here all the time. The are friendly, cordial, and meticulous with the repairs I have needed. They provide a loaner car if the item is under warranty or will take more than a day. As nice as the folks are at Jacksonville Chrysler Jeep Dodge have been, and as good as they are on dealing on new cars and making timely correct repairs, they have never provided me with a free loaner car.
Then again, my average Jeep Grand Cherokee Limited V8 major service or REPAIR bill has been less than $600 (they DO provide a loaner for major service OVER that amount). My average bill at the Porsche Dealer is about $2,000 when I take it in. No matter WHAT happens to the Porsche or whatever needs repair, the bill somehow always ends up in that range. Of course the Porsche was almost $100k new. Bob Snodgrass himself once had a bumper sticker on his Mercedes S600 that said "Hundred Thousand Dollar cars are made of Thousand Dollar parts."
And WHICH of these three wagons will draw the MOST attention in ANY parking lot FROM any age GROUP or any social strata?
Ahhhhhh, yes.
Red, gotta be red.
8) Mark
Fast cars
Fast boats
Fast women
Not necessarily in that order
Share This Thread